Hate Watch: Dancing With the Stars - Disney Night

I can show you the world. Or I can show you my thoughts on the Disney tie-in we got pre-semifinals and pre-Grammy night. Since I'm already running out of time let's just do the second one.
Opening with the Lion King seems about right, since it was the smash hit on Broadway. But also, the singer is absolutely nailing this. Am I not complaining about an interstitial? I am…not? But look, Disney had me from the beginning. I’m not exactly a Disney adult, but I am not NOT one. Oo! We’ve got a Newsies reference? Cool. Greatest Showman? I need to see that. The on the nose-ness of the Greatest Show part is not lost on me.
This had to happen, since it’s streaming on Disney. And it's to be Cruella for Julianne. Man, I need the lore behind all this. Also those bangs are cruel, not Cruella.
I'm already trying to guess everyone from their outfits in the short glimpse we got at the beginning. I'm also laughing my ass off with Amber, who I think is Herc? That’s kind of amazing. Haven’t got everyone nailed down yet, but we’ll see. Jenna is Belle, ok. And Connor as Flynn Ryder is just good casting. Ok, this will be fun. I hope they don’t ruin the music.
Oh shit. Cynthia Erivo’s here. They give her a nice big entrance to the main Disney theme. That’s gotta mean her status with the House of Mouse is elite. She’s eating it up. I wonder what it’ll be like to see her judge this. She wants expression, and hopefully we’ll get it. Alfonso seems a little starstruck. I wonder if he’s a Broadway sort.
Meanwhile, Maura is Tinkerbell and that’s a good one too.
Ezra has Aladdin. Ok, cool. No Ariel though? I’m personally let down by this.
Amber Glenn and Pasha - Quickstep - A Star is Born - Hercules
I loved that they made her Herc but it’s cooler that that’s sort of been her lore all along. Oo, they’re gonna switch leads. It’s a showoff piece and this should be a good thing for her, even if quickstep is hard.
Pasha got his moment in the beginning. I really like the character play here. Her frame is looking killer. I feel like they came in early on one phrase, but she’s killing it otherwise. Very light on the feet.
Let's see how we start out this evening:
Cynthia remarks on how joyful this was to start with, and I agree. It's a great kickoff. She says that her strength is fun to watch, and that this was just divine. I have no notes on her notes.
Bruno says Amber has the strength of Hercules and the beauty of Diana. There was another god reference in there but I didn't write it down. He does mention the misstep I thought I saw, but he's totally into it too.
Meanwhile, Carrie's wondering if this is the first time a woman's led a man on the show, and if it is, then it's about time. She says otherwise that it was crisp, clean and smooth, though she also noted the misstep.
Derek is over the moon, and says "A star is born and her name is Amber" and fails to mention the misstep which I find odd.
Scores are as follows: Carrie 8, Derek 9, Cynthia 8, Bruno 9
About right.
Maura Higgins and Mark Ballas - Jive - You Can Fly - Peter Pan
So the lore here is that people already called her Tink but that's only because of her accent. It's a weak association but we'll take it, I guess. She's seeming to be hard on herself this week because she's not an actor or an athlete, but there are skillsets from being a model that can be used in dance- like frame, poise, etc.
The first thing I don't like - this is a weird song for a jive. Like, I like the song, and I like the jive, but like...why do we keep doing this. There had to be better choices. Meanwhile, not a huge fan of this choreo. I felt like they did the same spin at the end like 50 times. Also, did I see Wayne Brady out there in the audience?
Let's go to judging:
Bruno says she had the captain by the hook and calls the performance saucy. He notes that the jive wasn't bad at all (which doesn't mean it was good) but that she needs more elasticity through the legs.
Carrie calls it a little low energy and encourages her to take care of herself.
Derek echoes the energy level problem and says it's a hard dance, and she needs a little more snap, but it was "pure cinema" to watch. I hard disagree.
Cynthia has an apt critique, saying that when you have fun, it shows in your face, and confidence is key. There were definitely moments that happened for her, but it wasn't all the time, so I think this is as much admonition as it is compliment. She also says she believes her as Tinkerbell, and despite the loose ties, I do too.
Now, for me, it's a weird time to learn this, but it's here we find out that Ray Chew, the bandleader on the show, has won a Daytime Emmy, which is cool. And to be clear this is a hard job. I don't say "the music is bad" because the band is bad, or because it's performed badly, it' sjust the choices. And I don't think that's down to him.
We cut to Julianne, in the sky box, with even more full length pleather gloves. Maura calls what happened Tinker Hell. I mean, I didn't think it was horrible, but the jive is really hard so I get it.
We get solid 8s all around. Ok. Side note: Her costume is amazing.
Tatyana Ali and Jan - Contemporary - Easy as Life from Aida
So it’s not just “traditional” main line Disney. Contemporary will be interesting for Tatyana. We're reminded that she got a four last week, and I think that was harsh. They’re leaning into that sort of grounded, elegant thing with her and it suits her. If it’s powerful emotions they’re looking for she can do that.
She's given such a classic "contemporary" costume, but she looks so light and elegant. This is suiting her well. We get a special guest in Heather Headley, star of Aida, performing live.
Now to judges:
Carrie said she got chills, and that there was true depth and emotion, alongside good pacing, grace, class and elegance. That says a lot and I agree. I'm hoping this bodes well.
Derek says that dance is emotion made visible. I swear he's pitching for a merch line of dance quotes. He mentions her divine feminine energy, too, and says he wants her here next week, and encourages her to reach further.
Cynthia starts out by saying that the emotion flows from her so easily and that it's beautiful to watch. She also gives her a tip as a fellow short girl, and says that she should think of herself as longer and taller than she is, so she gets that extension.
Meanwhile, Bruno loved it. He says "I'm Italian, it's in my blood. Dramatic soprano spirito." I love this for him. He talks a little about reach also.
She’s not sure how she did, but she has an entire hype squad in the skybox, so she's doing ok. She mentions how m uch harder this was than she thought, and how she couldn't have done this stuff prior to this point, and that is so honest.
Scores?
Carrie 9, Derek 8, Cynthia 8, Bruno 8.
Seems about right.
Harry Shum Jr and Jenna Johnson - Jazz - Supercalifragilisticexpialadocious - Mary Poppins
Full perfection. I'm excited for this because jazz was already his thing, but he loves Dick Van Dyke, and he's so theatrical I can't see how this would miss. They have a Make a Wish guest to dance with, that's cool. I thought they were gonna include them in the final dance but spoilers, they didn't. I have high hopes here, and he's not even one of my pets. Let's see what develops, eh?
Right away, he's channelling Dick Van Dyke. He's got an incredible leap in there, and then he nails that crazy knee walking thing that was from the original choreo. I knew he'd eat this alive. My notes just say "Hell yeah!" at the end, and that's the exuberance I think just came out of him onto this stage.
Derek's first words are "Get this man on Broadway, STAT!" and RIGHT? That toe touch though. Apparently Derek worked with Dick Van Dyke and thinks he'd have loved this. I agree.
Cynthia brings up his Van Dyke channel but also mentions Charlie Chaplin and says it was legendary movement and comedy. She commends the intricacy and says she's flabbergasted. You've flabbered her gasts, sir! And this is Cynthia Erivo!
Bruno said a lot of things that mostly amount to "yay!"
Carrie says that the nuances are fantastic and that he was precise and clean, and yeah. Understatement.
We get 10s across the board and honestly? Warranted.
Ezra and Daniella - Samba - Under the Sea - The Little Mermaid
Prince Eric wasn’t in that song or sequence! Ok, now that that’s out of the way... I for some reason thought he was Aladdin from that first look. They're lacking a bit fro mlast week but I think he can pull it off. It won't be easy though. I do love the set and the costumes.
I'm not super feeling it as they get into it, and I'm not sure why they cut away when he was going to be coming down the stairs. I do like that lean at the end though. I thought it was academically fine but I just never caught the hype, which at this point, you need.
Judges?
Cynthia says her temperature was going up. Interesting. She mentions that Daniella's skirt got tangled but magically came out.
Bruno says he looks like a prince but dances like a devil, asking where those hips come from, and honestly? He nailed that, and I thought it'd be hard.
Carrie says that he makes the impossible possible, and that he told the story, and was animated. My problem with her critique of him so far is that it's always like this. Again, what he's doing doesn't need the qualifier that's implied of "amazing because you have a disability" and I wonder if he feels that sometimes.
Derek says something that at first seems along those lines but it's actually Ezra's own words, that it might look a little different but he can do anything. See, that's empowerment, and it comes from within yourself, not from someone else telling you it looks different. Derek mentions the cruzados walk, hip action, whisks, voltas, and samba rolls, and says he had "all the content in the world, executed to perfection." That's how you compliment an incredible dancer.
Alfonso relates to the worries they had. This puts Maura at the bottom, which is unusual. Ezra has a lot to say about Daniella believing in him because he seems to really have not thought this dance was possible, but it sure didn't look impossible in the least when he did it.
Alfonso knows what they were worried about going in.
Here's the scores:
Carrie: 9, Derek 10, Cynthia, 9, Bruno, 9
Ok, I would’ve argued if it was all 10s, but I'm ok with this.
Something something Team Dance round? O...kay. I've never made it this far. So I have no idea what to expect. I mean, a little idea, but how it plays out I don't know. We still have dances first though, like the Julia Stiles pasa doble.
Julia Stiles and Ezra Sosa - Paso Doble - Satisfied - Hamilton
They have a vendetta from last week. 4. She wants to forget it and kill it this week.
She loves Hamilton and Lin Manuel. I get it. He's brilliant. Just like her.
Someone somewhere utters the phrase "If Julia can nail the intensity" and like, intensity is her thing. Her entire problem sometimes is that she's too intense. So hopefully she pours her intensity into this in a good way.
But oh no! She has an injury - a rib problem, and that sounds significant. I hope she can still kill it.
She does embody the character fully. I got distracted by her friends because I wonder, who are her friends? Where are they from, and how long have they been friends?
Let's see if our judges fill in the blanks:
Bruno mentions that he could see every nuance of the character - and that it was a proper paso doble with Spanish lines, elements of flamenco and plenty of content.
Carrie mentions that she sees her digging deep, and there's real emotion and beautiful dancing. She loved it and thought it was great.
Derek mentions last week's setback but says a setback is a setup for a comeback, and she delivered that. No 4s, ok? No 4s.
Cynthia says she looked ready and was digging in, and that to not look like what she's going through takes strength.
She’s over the moon so I hope her scores reflect that.
8, 8, 8, 9. I think she deserved another 9. Grr.
Pause a moment for the Julianne wardrobe commentary. PVC dress, PVC gloves, weird dot turquoise things. THE BANGS. Cruella or not they're not being kind to Julianne again. I don't know what this is about. I read somewhere that she wanted to be fashion forward and not look costumey but like, did anyone get that memo?
Onward.
Jenna DeWan and Val - Quickstep - Be Our Guest - Beauty and the Beast
Intro package commentary: It feels like she just wanted to see her boo, but y’know, whatevs. Did everyone ELSE get a consult? I’m sorry, I’m weird sometimes. Aww, but he loves seeing her dance.
Meanwhile, as to Jenna and VAl - he’s a good beast. She’s a good beauty. And she's keeping up with him on steps. Nice long lines, impeccable footwork. I mean, I think that was more or less flawless, and it was such a hard dance.
Judges?
Carrie calls her a perfect princess - quick and light and in sync. She says she was perfection.
Derek says that that's what he loves to see in a quickstep - she kept her top line still, it was magnificent, elegant, glorious. Derek is all about this, and like, ok, me too.
Cynthia is in love with the fun of it, and calls her split jump amazing (which it totally was.) She believed them as the characters.
Bruno says it was a banquet, and that Jenna delivered right up with the best that DWTS had to offer. High praise!
Ok, like, honestly, I do agree. Quickstep is hard and that was done so flippin’ well. The Jenna is a ringer people are gonna be SO MAD.
The Jenna is a ringer people are gonna be SO MAD.
What about those scores?
Carrie: 10, Derek, 10, Cynthia 10, Bruno 10.
Yeah, honestly like, I can’t argue. Even if i didn’t like the dance, I’d not argue. This makes it a tie at the top- what does this mean? They’ll tell you later.
And now?
A whole sneak peek at Hexed. I’m ok with this. It's more in line with what I expect.
Cuz this feels special, like a treat, instead of forced on us. Maybe I’m old fashioned.
Connor Wood and Rylee - Waltz - I See The Light - Tangled
Connor's last week was really good, and Rylee really seems to love him. The admiration seems mutual and genuine between them. Does dancing actually lead to falling in love? I bet this is a ship that's about to set sail.
I love Tangled and I love the set they did for this. She's gorgeous and they're looking incredible as they take the floor. Is he a dark horse? Is that a Tangled joke?
Who'd have thought you could be romanced by a waltz in 2026 but here we are.
Setting this ship sailing is Derek, who said he felt like this was the first dance at a wedding because of the OBVIOUS chemistry between them. He also calls him the king of faux facial hair. He mentions having control of the lower half in a slow waltz and says his frame is still getting there but that it was a beautiful waltz.
Cynthia says that Connor had a great committment to storytelling and with this last commentary I want her to judge more things. I feel like she's honest, encouraging and knowledgeable and she manages them all at once.
Back to sailing that ship, Bruno says the connection was honest, and mentions the frame and asks for a littel more sweep.
Similarly, Carrie tells Connor to work on being lead, and guide the dance.
Ok, well, Carrie is an 8, Derek 8, Cynthia 8, and Bruno 8.
I feel like a 9 was due from someone here, but either way, he really came up.
Team Dances:
Team Dances are next? First up is Team Slaytopia. Oh I’m not into the team names thing.
Here's an Aladdin dance, and whoever is the genie is a really good genie. Sherri Shepherd. I could see her being Genie on stage or in a live action, as gainst those as I’ve been.
So a tie means cumulative points across the seasons. Interesting totalling thing. Harry and Jenna win immunity but by one point. Interesting math ain’t it. I mean that though. It is.
Back to team dances.
Each team does a dance, earns one team score out of 40. Julianne and Alfonso and the stars have to dance a section with them and with the pros, but the judges are scoring the team and not them.
Alfonso is serious about this. Tatyana drew Alfonso. It had to be this way. Tatyana is the team captain and this might actually be interesting at this point in the competition. Alfonso and the girls is gonna be great. He has to show up, and I would hate anyone else calling her baby sis, but with him it's ok.
Still though, Slaytopia is a name I would not be proud of. I do like the outfits and the choreo. Alfonso is better than you'd think. Why do I really like this? Or why do I love it? They did a really great job.
Let's get TEAM judging:
Cynthia puts it simply and says "I had so much fun."
Bruno says it was a well trained menagerie. He loves the samba rolls. As for Julia, he says "you let your hair down beautifully. " and she really did.
Carrie says that the staging was great, with clean lines.
Derek says he loves team dances, and that it was well done.
That was uninformative. So it'll be interesting to get the scores.
9s across the board for...Slaytopia. I'd have taken off a point for the name, but I'm a jerk like that.
I do want those silk shirts - they're an incredible color.
Team Wildcats are up next, and - oh my god. These team names. I think the fifth graders could do better. Connor's team captain here and I like that. Meanwhile Julianne is gonna dance, and I can't wait to see it because I know she's amazing and I want her to be amazing. Again, I know I'm always bagging on her but again, not her, the way they write for her and dress her.
It’s ok. Be a dork. Team Wildcats!
Seriously though they're in school outfits. I almost forgot it was High School Musical they were doing and that it was Disney Night. Ignore me. Jenna shows the hell off in this one. Julianne is on the judge's table, which is a nice touch. Harry and Jenna might actually be the best dancers. I can't take my eyes off them.
See? Why can’t we just let her be a dancer.
And now the judging:
Bruno says they brought the A game. It's close to what you say but not quite.
Carrie calls it a fabulous way to end a great night, and I get that.
Derek gets weirdly emotional - because there's so much joy in the room. The team and Connor - everyone was sensational, he says, overwhelmed.
Cynthia says she legit felt like it was the opening of a show on Broadway - all the energy, and it was succinct and beautiful. It really, really was. She said that she could've seen that on a stage and that it was amazing, and I think that's accurate. Again, I'd trust Erivo to judge anything from here on out. She calls out Connor for having "way too much fun" and honestly, yeah. I think that was awesome.
Connor, meanwhile, says he "fell for it and it was in our own dance" and yeah, you really joymaxxed this one.
SO let's see the judges scores:
Full 10s. I was rooting for Slaytopia, but I feel like this did top that.
In the end we gotta do the sad stuff though. And it's Julia Stiles going home.
I'm sad, she's sad. She says it's been incredible, and that it pulled things out of her she didn't even know where they came from. She also mentions that she'll be sad not to see Ezra every day, mentioning that it was an absolute honor. We're gonna miss you guys.
That's more like a Bambi beginning than a happy Disney ending, but such is DWTS.
Are we gonna hit Hates and Greats? Yeah.
Hates and Greats
Hates:
Hate the team names. Let's start there. Slaytopia? Team Wildcat? Just no.
Hate the jive You Can Fly choice. Still ahte a lot of musical things.
Hate that outfit, again, for Julianne, and I wish she could just dance and they could stop putting her in that stuff.
Greats:
Team Dances. There. I said it.
Alfonso, who continues to be great in every place they put him.
The dancing. People are really on a new level.
Sucks they all have to be chopped like heads of lettuce. Time to go to sleep, babies. There's more to come.




Comments