top of page

Hate Watch: Dancing With the Stars - Grammy Night

Writer: Marielle Bokor
Marielle Bokor
11 minutes ago
16 min read

Ok, let’s talk about it. It’s Grammy Night. So the music better be GOOD. I should’ve looked this up but do they do Disney and Grammy night every year? I saw some clips from a previous Disney night.


Naturally, we kick things off with a big opening dance number, and honestly, it's pretty good.

Here's where I admit that even though I'm far behind, and haven't been watching week to week (or maybe because I have been behind) I'm a little burnt out. So I might be a harsher judge.


Julianne has a much better opening dress. Pretty blue sequins. Kinda odd symmetry but I can handle that. Harry Shum has a very odd neon sparkle thing going on but we’ll take that. And it might just fit the music or mood.


We're dancing for all the glitter now kids! It's about to be semi-finals. I'm ready, because: burnout.


I think it’s just the length of these things. I do have ADHD but even if I didn’t, the choice to keep it 90 minutes by adding team dances and movie promos instead of cutting it down as the season goes on is slightly ill advised in my book.


Alfonso mansplains what a Grammy is and it's one of the few times I tire of him. I feel like they’re really filling for time here sometimes. I love how they hardly go back earlier than Lady Gaga in the montage package thing they no doubt got right from the Grammy committee.  But I'm cranky because I've been sick, so let’s just see what happens.



 

Ezra Frech and Daniella - Argentine Tango - Beyonce - Crazy in Love


Kicking it off with Beyonce, and this has to be sexy, but they’re giving brother and sister, and they know it. So he’s scared of that. Hopefully he brings it - and at least at first strut he seems to be.


This is a deeply weird rendition of Crazy in Love but I'm not gonna automatically hate it yet. I don't know if this was their strongest. I saw some good moments in there but I wasn't amazed. Let's see.


Carrie starts off with praise, saying it was the hardest dance. And then she says "Make your sister your lover for one night. It's fine."


Uh, what? Like, Alfonso, Ezra, and Daniella were like "No. Do not say that. Do not say that..." and I agree. You just made it so weird, Carrie. So so weird. She adds something about the element of danger, but that ship has sailed and all we're thinking about is how weird you just made it.


I mean, their faces literally froze like that. I'll just show you


Everyone thinks it just got weird.
Everyone thinks it just got weird.


“Sister lover that’s awkward” quips Alfonso, uncomfortably.


There's other judges, so let's just...do that.


Derek says they had good intimacy, and realizes how that sounds tagged on to what Carrie said. He mentions the embrazo was really good and demonstrates an embrazo on Bruno. He went for it, and it was surprisingly amusing. Hell of a broach too, my dude.


Bruno says the two of them were smoldering, and reminds Ezra she's married, cheekily, and, I think, to undo some of the weirdness. He says there were a few balance issues but otherwise, it was incredible.


We have to wait the break for a score, and here they are


Carrie 9, Derek 9, Bruno 9


Oh yeah, no guest judges.  That’s why it was weird. 


Off we go! Let's see just how weird things can get.




Amber Glenn and Pasha - Pasa Doble -  Bring Me to Life - Evanescence


This won for best hard rock performance in 2004? Why did I, someone who should’ve known this, not know this? I don't know how I missed it, I was so into Evanescence. Turns out, she was into the Evanescence too. Let’s do this thing. I’m curious how this turns out in paso doble form.  Paso doble, pasa doble? I should’ve lookd that up too.


Pasha says her internal power will lend itself to this and that’s a good point, cuz it’s aggressive and powerful.  She is projecting the power, even if again, weird song choice for this a little, at least at first. She’s pulling a face I’m not sure I like, but the moves seem well executed, even if again, I’m not sure I love this song for this.


Alfonso seems very thrilled though, so let's see what the panel thinks. 



Derek says that paso (so it is paso!) had power, precision and Pasha! Thats' all you need. He mentions that she could do with a little more stretch but that she's incredible, and the ballet knee spins were phenomenal.


Bruno says "Thunderbolts and lightning, the way you paso is frighteningly good." I've come to love his antics, because he's got the knowledge and heart behind it. He too mentions Amber's power, beauty and passion, and can't help but mention Pasha's pecs.


Carrie calls the performance absolutely stunning, noticing that she worked on the resistance - and held it all with strength and power but without force.  Sounds like she's impressed.


In our skybox interview, Julianne asks "Are you hoping to get in the semifinals?" and for real, who writes this shit? Is water wet? Do you, baseball player in the MLB, want to win the World Series? Come on now.


Scores are on deck:


Carrie 9, Derek 9, Bruno 10


I’m trying to figure out the math for how it works with three judges and the audience vote vs four judges.  Perhaps we'll never know.




Maura Higgins and Mark Ballas - Argentine Tango - Thong Song - Sisqo


First of all,  the Thong Song was a Grammy winner? But also, they chose it for this? Are we jumping a shark real hard? I have fears.


Maura, meanwhile, is in pain. Rib pain, to be specific, but it seems much more serious than the injuries we've seen so far, insofar as she ends up getting an X-ray and the intro package implies she might not dance. But she's here, and she's doing the thing. I was gonna make a bunch of Thong Song jokes before it got all serious.


It’s a better fit to the dance genre than Evanescence was to the paso doble weirdly.  OK, I spoke too soon.  I can't stand it. I do not know what they were thinking with the music. Put me down for hates. It’s supposed to be Grammy week, man.  The original song was at least catchy. This is weird. It takes me away from the dancing, but not enough to not notice she's doing really well, and not enough to not be dually impressed by the upside down hold at the end.


Alfonso can’t help but make jokes. I'm right there with you.



Judging:


Bruno says Maura looks expensive and high class, and the tango was too. He calls it sensual but elegant and smooth, and says that her poise was excellent. It was very very good.


Carrie says she's graceful but also a warrior for doing that dance with that injury, and calls it a work of art. Except the song (my two cents, sorry.)


Derek calls it sultry, seductive, and slinky. He praises the leg lines, lunges, and calls it captivating. He also calls out that last move - "that last move was hard." Yeah it was. That looked CRAZY.  She did good.


Alfonso’s still talking and they bring out the 30 second dance. Ok. So is that a clear the floor scenario? Because maybe it has a purpose. I still don't like it, it's far too short.


Julianne asks if she’s ok - and Maura said she pushed through even when she didn't think she could. I like that sort of fire.


Carrie 9, Derek 9, Bruno 9


Ok, that’s awesome really. I felt like she did a great job and I was saying that OVER the music.


I missed the rest of the commentary other than catching something about bonus points in a dance-off. So, it's not team dances from here? I'm so confused.



One of these people is in fact, Jenna DeWan.

Jenna and Val - Jazz - All For You - Janet Jackson


Jenna and Val killed it last week with Beauty and the Beast if you recall. If you didn’t, the package reminds you.  Oh yeah, and she's been to the Grammys, of course. She danced at the Grammys with N'Sync.  


If you keep mentioning all the dance gigs you’ve had, I have nothing to say except, maybe you’re a pro. I hate to say that, but seriously. She did a LOT of dance work with a lot of high profile people. How she’s not considered a professional I don’t know.  So far she's danced at the Super Bowl, for Mariah Carey, with N'Sync at the Grammys... SO…I mean I get she hasn’t done ballroom but like, Iunno.


Just me or was the timing off in the beginning? It's a cute outfit that directly nods back to her being IN THE ACTUAL MUSIC VIDEO FOR THIS ACTUAL SONG. It's a cute outfit and I like their chemistry. She's got the Janet moves down pat. She's bringing straight Janet and she's great to watch.


But seriously? Can we talk about it? I'm an outsider, remember. Have pros like Val ever danced such a high profile gig as the Grammys?  Maybe we are doing something wrong here. It was great to watch though.



Let's just see what the judges have to say:


Carrie tells Jenna that people are enrolling in jazz classes because of you and the dance she just danced. That's a little on Janet too. She says that she expected greatness and that Jenna delivered. Well, yeah, but that's the problem, no?


Derek says it's not about what you dance, it's how you dance it. He praises her texture and musicality and says she was "in the pocket." He also mentions that she's inspiring dancers, and that it's a privilege to see what she does on their floor.


Bruno says that Jenna was in the comfort zone. He says that she nailed the feel and the style of the classic music videos. She carried it. And for Val's part, he’s not surprised she outdanced him. Is that him saying something? Hmmm...


Argentine tango abounds tonight and it looks like we'll be seeing more of it before the night is through.


Up in the skybox, Jenna talks about how dancing now to Janet is full circle from dancing for her 25 years ago, and the producers pulled out a little surprise that Julianne introduces. It's Janet Jackson, who says she's honored to have Jenna dancing with ther, reminisces some about their time on tour (because she was in TWO of her biggest videos and did a WHOLE TOUR with JANET JACKSON)



Ok, I've very much formed an opinion here and I'm sticking with it.


But then it's time for judging.


Carrie: 10, Derek 9, Bruno 9


I feel like they made too big a deal out of her dancing experience here and it’s really kinda making me think the show is rigged. And I don’t want to think that, and I don’t like that it’s so present in my mind. I know that ballroom dancing is its own thing, but when you are trained in dance, genre switching is expected and common, and you DO have an advantage just being a dancer. 


They were saying it about Harry too but so far he’s been an actor who also danced on Broadway, and I get it, because a lot of celebs got their start in theater and some even in music videos but Jenna has been dancing her whole life and had a career in it, basically, and that’s a little bit different to me than just dancing here an dthere for shows and movies.


We'll see a tango from Tatyana Ali next.


There’s a Housewives tie-in?  But of course. This one’s cuz Hulu.




Tatyana Ali -Tango - Boom Boom Pow- Black Eyed Peas


Here's another one I didn't know had a Grammy, but I guess it was for the music video. Meanwhile, Tatyana has a Grammy certificate for something she did with Sesame Street, and it sounds neat.


Now they're not calling this an Argentine Tango so I guess it's just a tango then? Sharpness is key, but that's hard for her, as she's more fluid and smooth.


Will. I. Am is a friend of hers, but his first question on interview is "How do you do a tango to Boom Boom Pow?" and honestly, I appreciate the candor.


I like how they put her in a tux dress, and as she gets out on the floor she looks really good. Her footwork is incredible. That little bit of singing to the camera was amazing and brought so much attitude and spark. I think her frame was maybe not 100 percent, but overall she was on fire. Mr. I Am thumbs ups the whole thing as if to say "thanks for dancing to my music but also that was weird."


Derek says she had great power, and that it was a great moment to the camera with the lip syncing. We're so in sync.


Bruno says it was a Tarantino tango. Reservoir something. He really liked it.


Carrie says that she saw a new thing starting. Eye of the tiger. Do you see it?  So in sync.


Amber and Jenna are at the top. No wayyyy.


In the audience, Will I Am looks bemused at his own attendance at all this but happy for Tatyana


Carrie 9, Derek 9, Bruno 9.  Damn, ok. That was really good.

Her kids were there.  Bonus!




Connor Wood and Rylee- Argentine Tango - SexyBack - Justin Timberlake


Connor was really good last week. It wasn’t good enough for him I think, and he deserved better, but at least the team thing went well. It's to be more sexy Connor, but I think he's up for the challenge.


Meanwhile Rylee is just SO PRETTY. It kills me. To my eye she's still leading at times. He's trying though, and I'm not 100 percent on what I'm seeing. He's got studious face, not sexy face. I dunno. I wasn't all in on this one.


Were the judges?


Bruno calls it strong and moody, and he's into it. "You can lead" he assures him.


Carrie says it was very well done, but cautions that sometimes he loses his axis.


Derek calls him intentional, decisive, and strong.  "You were in control. I felt that." He says it was oneof his best dances. I mean, ok. I can see that, but if that’s true I don’t think it’s the same as what we already saw.


Carrie 9, Derek 9, Bruno 9


Everyone’s tying up. 


No one is safe from elimination. 


But then Harry is immune? What? Oh, safe from the Dance Off round. That’s a false advertising moment. They made immunity sound like immunity from elimination. It's not though, or it is?




Harry and Jenna - Salsa -  Die With a Smile - Lady Gaga


Last week highlights reveal that yeah, Harry's been killing it. We find out in our intro that he was born in Costa Rica and was around a lot of social dances, at least as an observer. He wants to celebrate that sort of social dancing, but turns out he's having a lot of emotions about it, because of the hardships his family faced in coming to America via Costa Rica.


He says he didn't realize he'd avoided doing salsa so long because of his family's struggles, but he missed it. He's having a lot of emotions about it, but when he gets out there, there's a joy and effortlessness about it that's really nice.


Alfonso really likes it, too.


Carrie says that this salsa made her smile - and that it had style and showmanship - and heart. 


Derek praises Harry for the lifts, and tricks, which he says seem effortless. He says it was a fantastic, complicated routine, but the bottom half needs some work, though the upper half is perfection.


Bruno says he was revved up and ready to go. He says Harry was barnstorming an extra spicy salsa.  He liked all the underarm turn sequences and asks Jenna if she's Elastigirl. Seems like he really felt this one.


In the skybox we find out that Jenna got her nose broken by Harry. Salsa elbow. Is it just me or did that seem like


Carrie: 10, Derek 9, Bruno 10. 


Oh wow, ok.


They already had immunity.  They’re not immune from elimination, they just have immunity from the dance off? Like, what does that entail? This feels like it means almost nothing.


We get another big dance number. To Chappell Roan. Let’s see how this goes. Derek is a huge dork and is bopping around in the judges stand. I’m ok with it. They didn't murder Chappell's song so that's good. I have to wonder, since it was such a big deal to get a girl leading, if half the people watching realize what a sad anthemic song this is for the LGBTQ crowd. It's a gorgeous song but it's heartbreaking, too.


No time for that though because now we've got... Dance Offs.




Dance Offs - Round 1 - Amber and Pasha Vs Ezra and Daniella


Dance offs?  No real explanation - but it’s Amber and Pasha vs Ezra and Daniella. They split the ballroom into two halves, everyone has the same same style of dance. This is a rumba dance off. 


It's to be a husband and wife rivalry because of course it is. Pasha wants the tricks to happen, Ezra is scared because he knows he has to bring it to win against Amber. More body action is in order for him.


Ok, as much as I'm annoyed this can't just be done for the night, I want to see it. Athlete vs. athlete and two of my frontrunners (not pets, frontrunners. My pets are down to Tatyana, because Julia went home.)


Is Daniella tiny or is Ezra really tall. I didn't notice it before someone said he was doing a good job dancing down to her level. Turns out he's 6'1 and she's 5'3 and that's almost precisely my height difference with my husband so the truth is yes, he's tall and she's short.


We're getting Brandy and Monica live for this one, and the rumba is to The Boy Is Mine


The Boy Is Mine Rumba Battle:


Ooo the chemistry with Ezra and Daniella is great. But Amber is so graceful and long. This format is hard to watch. It's really cute the way that they put it together and I love how they ended it with the girls with the girls and the guys hugging it out.


Derek calls it one of the most satisfying dance offs, and laments that it's a really tough call. He liked the mirroring they did where they did the same moves at the same time. 


Bruno loves that they celebrated each other’s talent.  He calls it true sportsmanship, and that's one thing I do like about the show in general.


Carrie agrees that they didn't make it easy for them. Competitiveness and love can coexist.  "I don't know. I don't want to do this." she says and that's so relatable, honestly.


To the skybox!


Ezra just says 'this is my teammate. '


They point out that it was fun that they got to switch partners.  He also mentions it's fun to go up against another gold medalist. Amber says it was incredible, she loved working beside him, and we’re family now. They really seem like friends. Then of course the other two are married.


Amber and Pasha take the win. Thus the trash will be taken out by Daniella.


2 bonus points to the total added. Oh ok, that’s how it works. Way to bury the lede.




Dance Off Round 2: Jenna and Val Vs Tatyana and Jan


So these guys have a cha-cha to do. Tatyana has game face and a fire costume, and I love her, so let's go. I kinda love her. She's my last remaining pet. I mean that in the most respectful way possible. It's just she's my super biased favorite cuz I love her in general, like I did Julia Stiles, so they both had extra sway and extra weight to their dances for me.


Maren Morris is live to sing her song, and that's excellent. Again, a bad fit for the dance type though.


Bruno starts out the accolades with one for Jenna, repeating her "I've never done this before" and chuckling. He says it was a different interpretation but it looks so good. He switches to Tatyana saying that she's more sultry. "Diamonds and pearls. Difficult to call."


Carrie noticed the dichotomy too. She notes that Jenna's clean and neat and Tatyana is sultry.


Derek says the teamwork was nice but doesn't say much else.


To the skybox!


And Julianne thinks they look like Skittles. Ok.


Jenna and Val win this one.




Connor and Rylee Vs Maura and Mark


Now I don't know much, but I do know if those pants look like that, it's a Latin dance. I tire of those pants, and not from just this show. We need new Latin ballroom pants. Someone phone...someone.


We're about to cha-cha to All I Wanna Do by Sheryl Crow.


Connor knows he has to be expressive. Meanwhile, Sheryl Crow is also actually here. I still think if we got Janet, Brandy and Sheryl Mariah should've showed up for her whole week. But what do I know? Connor and Rylee are out on the floor looking good and having fun. But Mark and Maura are very technical, elegant and awesome, and still bring fun in their faces.


This worked better than some other songs, and I really love Sheryl Crow. Let's see what our judges have to say.


Carrie says it was so much fun but that they were very different. She mentions a lot of country line dancing, directing that at Connor and Rylee, and I noticed that, but like, THAT MAKES SENSE for Sheryl Crow. She thinks it isn't what you want to see in the cha-cha. I want to see the music match the dance genre, thank you!


Derek calls it "really interesting" and clarifies that he meant that in the best possible way. He tells Connor his performance was good and he had good charisma, and calls Maura gorgeous and classy. He debates whether to choose performance or technique.


Bruno calls it cheeky and sexy. I'm not exactly sure who. Maybe all of them.


Mark has cool tattoos. That's a complete aside.


In the end, Maura and Mark take it.


Final Leaderboard:


Harry, then Amber, then Jenna.  Maura Connor Ezra and Tatyana at the bottom.




Semifinals - 


Harry and Jenna are IN. Amber and Pasha are in, so are Ezra and Daniella.


Also in the semifinals are Maura and Mark. Our "no particular orders are Connor and Rylee, so that makes it Tatyana or Jenna. I have upsets.


Results:


Jenna and Val get eliminated? What? WHAT? Ok, for multiple reasons that shocks me, but I'm also relieved because Tatyana is a favorite and has been doing so well. Did they correct their error here? Did the audience correct it?


All love, Jenna says. And Jenna and Harry have a nice moment, and then we're out.


Time to hit Hates and Greats.






Hates and Greats:


Hates:


  • Music: So much of the music doesn't go with so much of the dancing. Like, we don't have to turn Sheryl Crow music into a cha-cha. And honestly, there was probably a genre we could've turned it into that would've been better.


  • Julianne's inane commentary: Do you want to go to the semi-finals? Is water wet? If not, why are you even here?


  • Bloat: I'm sorry but we could've done without the random extra Team Dance, Dance Off things. Sure, they're fun and all, but so is the half hour of free time you get if you don't watch that. This also includes dumb product placement shit.


  • The Jenna Situation: I have no hate for Jenna. She's really, really talented. But she is by the most basic definition a professional dancer. Of some status. Like, if you get hired on Janet Jackson's tour, and get hired for the Super Bowl, and get hired for the Grammys...you're a professional dancer, not just a celeb who dances. There is a distinct difference. Who thought this was a good idea?


Greats:


  • Cameraderie: It's really awesome to see friendly competition shows, where people help and support each other. I've been over the whole "you gotta play the game" cutthroat thing in reality television since damn near when it started.


  • Costuming: I still really love the costumes. Ballroom can be gaudy and out of touch, but I don't think it is here. I mean, ok, I did complain about the Latin dance pants, but it's just because they're overused.


  • Sets: I also love the sets - they really do the most for the contestants and create a whole world. That crew must be enormous and highly skilled.


  • Voting: I complained about this before and I might again. BUT if the show doesn't police itself, at least popular opinion can. And that's what I will say about that.

Comments


Contact
Culture Combine

Thanks for submitting!

  • X
  • Grey Instagram Icon
  • Grey Facebook Icon

© 2023 by The New Frontier. Proudly created with Wix.com

bottom of page